19 November 2026

Back-to-back rollovers – ATO issues guidance

Peter Feros, George Hempenstall

Rollovers under the capital gains tax (CGT) provisions are useful tools that allow taxpayers to disregard a capital gain in circumstances where the consideration received is in illiquid form (e.g. shares), provided certain conditions are met. 

In the context of certain transactions and restructures, CGT rollovers which are back-to-back (i.e. in succession) for the same underlying asset mean that (putting aside general anti-avoidance rules) tax on capital gains can be deferred until such time as the taxpayer is in a position to realise, in a liquid form, the value of their investment. 

The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has finally released its guidance around back-to-back rollovers, raising concerns in respect of transaction steps which technically comply with the law, but which when combined result in a capital gain being disregarded when it would not have been had the transaction been undertaken more directly. Transactions which have the effect of uplifting basis or deductions which utilise back-to-back rollovers are also the focus of the ATO’s guidance. The ATO asserts that Part IVA, Australia's general anti-avoidance rule, may apply to cancel the resulting tax benefits.

In Draft Practical Compliance Guideline PCG 2026/D5 (published on 11 November 2026) (the Draft PCG) the ATO outlines its proposed compliance approach to “lower risk” or “higher risk” back-to-back arrangements and the application of Part IVA. The framework sets out factors that will be considered in deciding whether the ATO will have cause to devote compliance resources to further examining such arrangements. 

Below, we outline the features the ATO has identified as indicating lower and higher risk back-to-back rollovers. Where each rollover is underpinned by genuine commercial purposes, the arrangement is likely to fall into the lower risk category, and back-to-back rollovers remain a useful structuring tool. However, taxpayers bear the onus of establishing that Part IVA does not apply, so contemporaneous records of the commercial rationale for each step are essential. Recent Federal Court decisions in the Commissioner's favour illustrate how difficult that onus can be to discharge: Hilton (a pre-sale restructure) and Merchant (a related party sale).

The ATO has invited comments on the Draft PCG by 11 December 2026. 

“Higher risk” back-to-back rollovers

In the Draft PCG the ATO has flagged the following factors that, together, indicate a “higher risk” arrangement for the application of Part IVA where back-to-back rollovers are deployed:

  1. Interdependency: The rollovers are executed as part of a single agreement, overarching strategy or coordinated undertaking, or the undertaking of one transaction is conditional upon the execution of another transaction. Interdependent rollovers can occur contemporaneously or over an extended period of time – it is noteworthy that the threshold of interdependence adopted by the ATO does not necessarily require legal interdependence.  As such merely because a particular step is not conditional on another occurring, that does not prevent the steps being interdependent under the ATO’s interpretation.
     
  2. Intermediate step with no apparent purpose: The transaction involves an intermediate step that serves no or limited apparent purpose beyond enabling a further rollover to be applied; and
     
  3. A higher risk indicator is present: Compared with undertaking the transactions more directly, one or more of the following outcomes arise:

a. gain deferred: a capital gain is disregarded, or an asset keeps its pre-CGT status;

b. cost base uplift: leaving aside external economic or market forces, a future capital gain is reduced or a future capital loss is increased (for example, through a higher cost base, including via the tax consolidation cost-setting rules); or

c. increased deductions: capital allowance deductions increase because the rollovers produce a higher cost for depreciating assets.


A higher risk rating does not mean Part IVA will necessarily apply, however these arrangements carry an increased likelihood of ATO review activity, which would include a deeper consideration of whether Part IVA should apply and whether the eligibility conditions have been met. This applies whether the rollover transactions occur contemporaneously or over an extended period.

The Draft PCG provides the following examples of higher risk arrangements:

  • undertaking a Subdivision 124-N rollover (trust units in exchange for shares in newly established private company) followed by a Subdivision 124-M rollover (private company shares exchanged for shares in a widely held company), in the absence of any commercial purpose for the intermediate step aside from creating the conditions for Subdivision 124-M rollover eligibility;
     
  • undertaking a Subdivision 122-A rollover (business assets transferred to NewCo) followed by a Subdivision 124-M rollover (private company shares exchanged for shares in the acquiring company), where the objective intention was to transfer business assets to the acquiring company and defer the capital gain; 
     
  • undertaking a Subdivision 124-M rollover (scrip for scrip) followed by a Division 615 rollover (interposing a company) and tax consolidated group formation, where the objective intention is uplifting the tax costs of high value assets to reduce the capital gain on their disposal; and
     
  • undertaking a Subdivision 122-A rollover (business assets transferred to NewCo) followed by a Subdivision 124-M rollover (private company shares exchanged for shares in the acquiring company) and tax consolidated group formation, where the tax cost setting process on consolidation increases the tax cost of assets and consequently, the amount of deductions. 
     
“Lower risk” back-to-back rollovers

In the Draft PCG the ATO flags the following factors that indicate a lower level of risk for Part IVA applying to back-to-back rollovers:

  1. Independent transactions: Transactions will be independent (and therefore lower risk) where they are not part of a single agreement, overarching strategy or coordinated undertaking, and the undertaking of one transaction is not conditional upon the execution of another transaction. In the Draft PCG the ATO offers the following example:
     
    • a sole trader to company business assets rollover, as a company is a more effective business structure to encourage and manage rapid growth; and
    • 6 months later, an unrelated party approaches with a view to acquiring the company. A merger is instead agreed with a scrip for scrip rollover undertaken.
       
  2. Steps are directed to overall objective and commercial purpose: The steps taken as part of the arrangement are individually directed at the substantive commercial outcome sought to be achieved (beyond any tax outcomes achieved).

A lower risk rating is less likely to attract compliance attention, however the Commissioner flags that he may still determine Part IVA applies if the Commissioner has cause to further examine the arrangement.

JWS comments

The Draft PCG has not provided any real surprises around the Commissioner’s views of back-to-back rollovers. It puts taxpayers on notice that the CGT rollover provisions are not “choose your own adventure”. It is not enough for each step to satisfy the rollover conditions in isolation; the purpose of each step, objectively assessed, also matters. If an intermediate step is carried out solely for a tax purpose (e.g. enabling another rollover), Part IVA may apply. Consistent with the recent Hilton decision, the ATO continues to press arguments that Part IVA can have application where a simpler way of undertaking a transaction might have been available, notwithstanding the simpler way involved a tax cost.

In practice, many genuine back-to-back CGT rollovers will be interdependent, and will involve a deferral of a capital gain, so the key question that needs answering – with a view to mitigating Part IVA risk – is the purpose of any intermediate step, and whether it is purely designed to achieve another CGT rollover, or whether it has an objective, commercial end individually. 

It is clear from the Draft PCG that back-to-back CGT rollovers, when deployed together with the tax consolidation cost base resetting provisions, require special consideration. Taxpayers need to be particularly careful to document commercial drivers and context – such as refinancing, succession planning or positioning for an external sale – when deploying rollovers together with the choice to form a consolidated group. 

While transactions designed for the sole purpose of achieving a basis uplift through the use of back-to-back rollovers may be of concern to the ATO with some justification, in the context of a genuine third party transaction which involves the provision of scrip consideration, the Draft PCG adopts an approach which is disappointing.  There are a few key observations to be made here:

  • In many transactions involving back-to-back rollovers eg 122-A (which applies to an exchange of business assets for NewCo shares) followed by 124-M (which applies to an exchange of NewCo shares for buyer shares), the counterfactual for Part IVA purposes will be a direct sale of assets to a NewCo (which might be established by a financial sponsor or by an existing corporate group). This raises a number of questions which require a close examination of the facts before reaching a concluded view: 
     
    • Is that counterfactual transaction a materially more “direct” transaction (and therefore a more appropriate transaction) than the seller incorporating NewCo, transferring assets to NewCo, and then selling NewCo shares?  In each case, one of the parties needs to set up a company and, in each case, there needs to be an asset transfer.
       
    • Why should it matter whether the seller facilitates the incorporation of NewCo and asset transfers? Further, depending on the facts, the seller may be better placed to obtain counterparty consents, novate contracts and transfer employees and licences. 
       
    • Why should the additional step involving the sale of shares in a newly incorporated (and therefore “clean”) company mean that Part IVA risk is materially greater, noting that a sale of shares is, for larger transactions, the more common method for buying and selling non-passive businesses? We note that an asset sale was accepted as a reasonable counterfactual by Younan J in Hilton (currently on appeal to the Full Federal Court), but the preferred reasonable counterfactual – despite accepting that an asset sale was market practice in Australia at the time for hotels – was sale of shares in a NewCo. 
       
  • A sole trader transferring business assets to a company (and obtaining rollover under Subdivision 122-A) effects a real and permanent change in the profile of the business (e.g. ringfencing liabilities, and financing), and some of these aspects appear to have been overlooked by the ATO in the Draft PCG. 
     
  • At a policy level, why should a genuine third party transaction involving scrip consideration be deemed offensive merely because of an intervening step which converts the target assets into the form of NewCo shares? Perhaps there is a perception that the seller has benefited (particularly in the case of a trust) from the more “tax-transparent” structure and this means that they should not be able to cherry pick the benefits of a trust structure and the benefits of a corporate structure. We do not think that should be a relevant consideration.


Ultimately, the position taken by the ATO leaves taxpayers with a high degree of uncertainty.  While we expect that back-to-back rollovers will still have a place in certain transactions, for those wishing to pursue the certainty of a tax ruling, we think it will become more difficult to get any guidance from the ATO on a timely basis (if at all). 

While there is a favourable class ruling CR 2015/12 (Bailador Siteminder Co-Investment Trust) on the use of back-to-back rollovers (albeit without addressing Part IVA), that class ruling is over 11 years old and, since that time, we have seen a hardening of the ATO’s position on various kinds of rollover (for example, demerger relief and the “and nothing else” requirement).  As such, placing significant weight on that class ruling absent consideration of other commercial drivers for the two-step transaction is not recommended.