
State Revenue authorities have significantly intensified their compliance and audit focus on non-employee (contractor) workforces, creating material financial and governance risk for business models involving independent contractors.
Under the “relevant contract” provisions of the payroll tax legislation in New South Wales (and other jurisdictions with harmonised payroll tax legislation), payments to contractors – including those operating through companies, partnerships or trusts, or trading as a sole-trader – can be deemed taxable wages unless a statutory exemption applies.
The recent (4 November 2026) High Court of Australia (HCA) decision in Uber Australia Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2026] HCA 40 has confirmed that digital platforms providing lead generation services and payment facilitation services to contractors can attract payroll tax on amounts remitted to those contractors. The High Court’s broad approach to the interpretation of the provisions signals that platform operators may not be insulated from payroll tax liability on the payments made to its users. The decision reinforces that courts will focus on the substance of commercial arrangements, by reference to the contractual obligations, rather than merely accepting the labels in the contract.
Beyond digital platforms, State Revenue authorities are heavily scrutinising arrangements with contractors in a variety of industries, including security, transport, labour hire, healthcare and medical centres, mortgage and financial broking networks, construction and cleaning. We have observed that revenue authorities will look at multiple ways to raise additional payroll tax liability, including the relevant contractor provisions and the employment agency provisions. Businesses that rely upon contractor workforces should revisit their payroll tax exposure in light of this decision, particularly where contractors are integral to the delivery of the businesses’ core services.
What did the High Court decide?
The HCA,by majority (Steward J dissenting) dismissed Uber’s appeal against a decision of the New South Wales Court of Appeal (NSWCA), affirming that amounts remitted by Uber to drivers were subject to payroll tax under the relevant contractor provisions of the Payroll Tax Act 2007 (NSW) (PTA).
The assessments issued by the New South Wales Chief Commissioner of State Revenue gave rise to payroll tax liabilities of approximately A$81million in respect of the 2015 to 2020 financial years.
Uber’s Business Model and the contractor provisions
Drivers contracted with Uber under Driver Contracts and accessed trips through the Driver App, while riders contracted with Uber through the Rider App. A driver could not access the Driver App without entering into a Driver Contract.
Although drivers could choose when to work and whether to accept a trip, once a trip was accepted they were subject to contractual obligations governing the transportation service.
Riders paid Uber directly through the Rider App and Uber deducted its service fee before remitting the balance to drivers.
At its core, the dispute concerned whether the transportation services provided, and the payments made to Uber drivers fell within the relevant contract provisions of the PTA. The provisions can deem payments made under certain service contracts to constitute wages, even where parties are not in a conventional employment relationship.
HCA reasons
The majority’s reasoning is consistent with a broader trend in judicial decision making: an increasing focus on the commercial substance and practical operation of a business model.
Uber contended that the contracts with the drivers were not relevant contracts because the:
- driving services were neither supplied to Uber, nor supplied under the Driver Contract;
- driving services were ancillary to the use of goods which are the property of the drivers (their cars); and
- amounts remitted by Uber to drivers were not amounts paid or payable by Uber to the drivers for or in relation to the performance of work relating to a relevant contract.
The majority of the HCA rejected each of these arguments based on the contractual framework under which Uber’s business model operated, and in particular, the terms of the Driver Contract that operated between a driver and Uber.
Driving Services Supplied to Uber under a Contract
The majority of the HCA accepted that drivers provide transportation services to riders. Importantly, it considered that the same services were also supplied to Uber under the Driver Contract and that those services formed an essential part of Uber’s business model. The application of subsection 32(1)(b) of the PTA requires the relevant contract to be characterised having regard to the parties’ rights and obligations.
In concluding that the drivers’ services were supplied to Uber for the purposes of subsection 32(1)(b) of the PTA, the Court noted, that whilst the Driver Contract does not oblige a driver to pick up any particular rider, once a driver has accepted a trip request, picked up the rider and the trip has begun the obligations imposed by Uber on a driver included delivering a rider to their destination.
The majority accepted that the mere fact that a person derives a benefit from another’s activities does not, without more, establish that services are being supplied to that person. By way of illustration, it was observed that a shopkeeper may benefit from a bus stopping outside a store, but that does not mean that the bus driver is supplying services to the shopkeeper. However, the relationship between Uber and its drivers was materially different.
Driving Services were not Ancillary to the Use of the Car
The majority rejected Uber’s argument that the driving services were exempt on the basis that they were ancillary to the use of the driver’s vehicle.
While drivers used their own vehicles, the majority considered that the primary object of the arrangements was the supply of the driving services not the use of the vehicle. While a vehicle was necessary to provide rideshare services, it was the drivers’ labour, performance obligations and transportation services that sat at the heart of the contractual arrangement and Uber’s business model.
On this basis the drivers’ services could not be characterised as ancillary to the use of their vehicles. As a result, the exemption in subsection 32(2)(a) of the PTA did not apply and the Driver Contracts remained relevant contracts for payroll tax purposes.
Payments to the Drivers were Deemed Wages
The majority also concluded, contrary to Uber’s contention, that the amounts remitted by Uber to drivers were payments made “for or in relation to” the performance of work, and therefore within the statutory definition of wages under section 35 of the PTA.
The majority found a clear connection between the payments drivers received and the driving services they performed. The requisite connection existed because both the fares paid by riders and the amounts remitted to drivers were calculated by reference to the driving services performed.
Further, Uber was not acting merely as a “limited payment collection agent”, notwithstanding the label used in the Driver Contract (noting that labels are not determinative).
The Dissent
The decision was not unanimous. Steward J dissented and would have allowed Uber’s appeal.
His Honour approached the relevant contract provisions by reference to their function as an anti-avoidance measure directed at arrangements that disguise what are in substance, employment relationships for payroll tax purposes. Steward J considered that the Driver Contracts did not require drivers to supply transportation services to Uber. Rather, the transportation services were supplied to riders, while Uber provided drivers with lead generation, payment processing and technology platform services through the Uber app.
Steward J also disagreed with the majority’s characterisation of the payment flows. In his view, Uber collected fares as the drivers’ limited payment collection agent and remitted those amounts to drivers after deducting its service fee. On that analysis, the remitted fares were payments by riders for transportation services supplied by drivers, rather than amounts paid by Uber for work performed for Uber.
Where to from here?
This decision does not mean that all contractor arrangements will be subject to payroll tax. Whether a contractor arrangement is subject to payroll tax depends upon the relevant legislative provisions, including any applicable exemptions, and the terms of the contractual arrangements that are in place.
Nevertheless, this decision highlights several features that revenue authorities are likely to scrutinise closely:
- contractors perform services that are integral to the business model;
- the business imposes significant contractual requirements as to how work is performed or how services are to be delivered;
- the business collecting payments from customers and remitting those payments to contractors; and
- reliance on a contractor exemption that may not apply or cannot be substantiated.
Businesses that operate in the gig economy and digital platform sectors should carefully assess their contractual arrangements and the potential payroll tax implications of this decision. For advice on the implications of the HCA’s decision, including contractor arrangements, payroll tax obligations and Revenue NSW disputes, please contact the JWS Tax Team.